| Platinum | Just Judy's Cakes & Designs LLC |
| Gold | Dairy Queen |
| Silver | Lorraine's Bake Shop |
| Bronze | Made by Molly, LLC |
| Top Pick | Bruster's Real Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Gigi's Cupcakes |
| Top Pick | Jozettie's Cupcakes |
| Top Pick | Lulu's Cake Shop |
| Top Pick | Martin's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Nancy's Italian Ice |